
Photo: President Asif Ali Zardari. Archive portrait, 2024. (President.az / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)
President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif agreed on Saturday that any move to create new provinces must strictly follow the Constitution, and that a referendum on the contentious issue would also require parliamentary approval. The understanding was reached during a meeting between the two leaders at the prime minister's Model Town residence in Lahore, amid a fresh debate over the creation of additional provinces.
Official sources privy to the development told Dawn that the two leaders agreed to "strictly adhere to constitutional provisions" governing the creation of new provinces or administrative units. "The majority in parliament will decide whether a referendum is to be held and what its question(s) should be. Without consensus, the matter cannot move an inch. Parliament cannot be bypassed," an official source quoted the meeting as agreeing.
President Zardari, who was accompanied by former prime minister Raja Pervez Ashraf and Senator Saleem Mandviwalla, made it clear that the PPP's position remained aligned with the Sindh Assembly's resolution opposing the creation of new provinces. He stressed that any move must follow the procedure prescribed by the Constitution.
What sparked the debate?
The discussion came two days after Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi floated the idea of holding a referendum to gauge public opinion on the creation of new provinces or administrative units, arguing that the exercise could settle the debate once and for all. The proposal has found support among cabinet members and within sections of the ruling PML-N.
The Presidency had already denied on Friday that new provinces were discussed when Naqvi met Zardari in Nawabshah, saying that meeting focused on national security and the regional situation. Saturday's meeting was the second high-level engagement on the issue in three days, and the heavyweight delegations underlined its political significance.
What is the government's plan?
According to PML-N sources quoted by The News, there is a proposal to create 12 provinces, dividing Punjab into four provinces and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan into three each, with two in Sindh. The federal government has completed its homework on a proposal to adopt the procedure for holding a referendum under Clause 6 of Article 48 of the Constitution, under which the prime minister can obtain permission from parliament for a referendum on an issue of national importance.
The same sources said approval would be taken from a joint session of parliament, with the Federal Constitutional Court as a fallback if a majority cannot be secured, and that a resolution on new provinces is expected in the Balochistan Assembly in the coming weeks.
Where do the parties stand?
The accounts of what was actually discussed in Lahore differ. Dawn's official sources describe a substantive agreement on the constitutional route. But Senator Saleem Mandviwalla, speaking to the Express Tribune, said the creation of new provinces had not been discussed and that the PPP had yet to take a position on the issue. The official statement from the Prime Minister's Office did not specifically mention the discussion on new provinces or the proposed referendum, saying only that the two leaders discussed the country's overall political, economic and security situation.
The PML-N will watch what the PPP and the PTI do, The News reported, and the PTI has not yet said whether it supports the proposed constitutional amendment. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Tariq Fazal Chaudhry said the PTI founder's views appeared to support new provinces, though the PTI has not publicly set out such a position.
What happens next?
No formal talks have yet been held with the PPP on the issue, Chaudhry said, and he is due to meet the PTI's chief whip on Monday, after which the party's position should become clearer.
For now, the reporting agrees on one guardrail: whatever the politics, parliament cannot be bypassed. Whether that holds when the proposal reaches a joint session — and whether the PPP's opposition to dividing Sindh can be reconciled with the PML-N's enthusiasm for a public vote — will decide the debate's course.
Related coverage on The Global Thinker: read our report on the latest counterterrorism operations in KP and Balochistan and Pakistan's call for dialogue at the UN. More Pakistan news: Pakistan News.
FAQ
What did Zardari and Shehbaz agree in Lahore?
According to official sources quoted by Dawn, they agreed that creating new provinces must follow the Constitution and that any referendum on the issue needs parliament's approval — "parliament cannot be bypassed".
What is the PPP's position on new provinces?
President Zardari reiterated the PPP's opposition to the division of Sindh, in line with the Sindh Assembly's resolution. The PPP has yet to take a formal position on the wider proposal, according to Senator Saleem Mandviwalla.
What would a referendum require?
Under the government's proposal, approval from a joint session of parliament under Clause 6 of Article 48 of the Constitution, with the Federal Constitutional Court as a fallback if a majority cannot be secured.
Comments
Post a Comment