Daily Pakistan & World News

Main Tags

Categories

Breaking

Advertisement

Zardari, Shehbaz Agree to Settle Issues by Dialogue

Zardari, Shehbaz Agree to Settle Issues by Dialogue

The Aiwan-e-Sadr (President House) building in Islamabad, seen down a wide avenue

Aiwan-e-Sadr (President House), Islamabad (file photo, 2005) — the meeting venue, not the meeting itself. (Shubert Ciencia / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0)

President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif have agreed that all matters between them will be resolved through dialogue and mutual consultation, the Presidency said on Thursday, after a meeting at Aiwan-e-Sadr in Islamabad aimed at cooling a coalition row that has dominated Pakistani politics this week.

The Zardari Shehbaz dialogue follows days of open friction between their parties. On Tuesday, PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari — the president's son — delivered hard-hitting remarks questioning past decisions of the ruling coalition and warning that any forced division of Sindh into new provinces could lead to bloodshed. Federal ministers hit back on Wednesday, and by Thursday the two men at the top of the coalition were sitting down together to contain the damage.

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, who has been at the centre of Bilawal's criticism and is an avid supporter of new administrative units, was also present at the meeting. The Presidency said the "current political situation was reviewed in detail", the Middle East conflict also came under discussion, and it was decided that the leadership will "sit down together on all matters and resolve them through consultation".

What the Presidency Said

The statement from President Zardari's office was short but pointed. It noted that "the previous constitutional amendments were passed through mutual consultation among all allied parties" — a reminder that the coalition has governed by consensus so far, and a signal that the PPP expects that practice to continue.

The meeting was the second between Zardari and Shehbaz in a week. According to official sources, their November 14 meeting had already produced an understanding that any move to create new provinces would stick to the constitutional process. Thursday's meeting restated that understanding in public, after a week in which it had looked badly frayed.

The row itself goes back further than this week. The debate over new administrative units gained momentum on July 31, when Naqvi called for additional provinces or administrative units to overhaul what he described as the country's outdated governance system. The proposal drew interest from the MQM-P, which has long advocated carving out new provinces from Sindh, and opposition from the PPP, which governs Sindh. On September 4, the Sindh Assembly passed a unanimous resolution opposing the province's division — a resolution the PPP has invoked ever since.

The Ministers' Response

Not everyone in the government is singing from the same hymn sheet. Minister of State for Interior Tallal Chaudhry, speaking on Geo News programme Aaj Shahzeb Khanzada Kay Saath, welcomed the Zardari-Shehbaz meeting as the right way to resolve differences, but he also pushed back on Bilawal directly.

"A matter about the people will be decided in a democratic manner, and you cannot exclude parties in that," Chaudhry said, adding that the discussion concerned administrative units for the whole country, not any one province, and that it was aimed at improving governance rather than serving anyone's wishes. He described Bilawal as "young and emotional", said the government's side had responded "only to an appropriate extent", and argued that "everything, from appointment to a grade-four post to becoming prime minister, has been decided through consultation here".

Chaudhry also ruled out any legislation on the matter without taking coalition partners into confidence, particularly the PPP, and said all legislation had been passed after thorough consultations with allies — a commitment the PPP will now hold him to.

Why This Meeting Mattered

The coalition between the PML-N and the PPP is the foundation of the current government, and it has survived by keeping its disagreements private. This week broke that pattern: a PPP chairman publicly questioning the coalition's decisions, ministers publicly answering him, and a debate about the map of the country conducted in television studios.

Thursday's meeting was an attempt to restore the old pattern. The two leaders agreed to talk rather than trade blows, restated the principle of consultation, and left the substance — whether new provinces will ever be created, and by what process — for another day. Bilawal himself, despite his criticism, has reiterated the PPP's support for Prime Minister Shehbaz and said political leaders should prioritise the country's economic challenges.

Whether the truce holds will be tested the next time the provinces question comes up in public. For now, the message from Aiwan-e-Sadr is that the coalition's disagreements will be settled across a table, not on television.

Related reading: 22 Terrorists Killed in KP Operations, ISPR Says and Petrol Up Re1 to Rs323 as 12-Cut Streak Ends. More Pakistan news: Pakistan News.

FAQ

What did Zardari and Shehbaz agree at their meeting?

That all matters will be resolved through dialogue and mutual consultation, according to the Presidency. The meeting at Aiwan-e-Sadr on Thursday also reviewed the current political situation and the Middle East, and was attended by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi.

What caused the coalition friction?

PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari's remarks on Tuesday opposing a referendum on new provinces and warning that a forced division of Sindh could lead to bloodshed, followed by strong criticism from federal ministers on Wednesday. The debate over new provinces began in July when Naqvi called for a governance "reset".

Has the PPP withdrawn support for the government?

No. Bilawal has reiterated the PPP's support for Prime Minister Shehbaz, and the Presidency's statement stresses that previous constitutional amendments were passed through mutual consultation among all allied parties.

Comments